Sourced fact
The News
UK former Attorney General Dominic Grieve has confirmed that Israel does not have the legal right to close the UK's general consulate in East Jerusalem. Grieve, who served as Attorney General from 2010 to 2014, sent a consultative paper to the British government asserting that closing the consulate contradicts international law, as the United Nations and the majority of its member states, including the UK, consider East Jerusalem to be occupied Palestinian territory.
Grieve stated that maintaining the UK consulate in East Jerusalem after recognizing the Palestinian state underscores the UK's position that the final status of Jerusalem has not yet been determined. He added that this maintenance does not imply recognition of Israel's sovereignty over East Jerusalem. According to Grieve, closing the consulate would negatively impact Palestinians by disrupting assistance, supervision, and monitoring from the West Bank and Gaza.
Lord Wood, the UK's Minister of State for Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Affairs, noted in the House of Lords that Grieve might have a valid point but warned that Israel could make the consulate practically non-functional. Wood also pointed out that closing the consulate could endanger British interests in the region.
Meanwhile, UK Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband condemned Israeli actions in Gaza and the West Bank at the ruling Labour Party conference, calling them "a stain on the conscience of the world." Miliband stressed that threats facing Israel do not justify the harsh responses that followed, reaffirming that under Andy Burnham's leadership, the Labour Party has redefined its stance and will adopt a more assertive position against Israeli violations.
Miliband also announced new steps targeting economic links with Israeli settlements, stating that Britain will go beyond financial data and move towards practical measures. He mentioned that Israel launched a violent attack on the Gaza Strip following the October 2023 attacks, resulting in the deaths of approximately 74,000 people and injuries to about 175,000 others, and the destruction of most of the area. Despite the ceasefire that came into effect in October 2025, Israel continued to launch attacks on Gaza, leading to the deaths of more than 1,400 Palestinians and injuries to around 5,000 others, according to the Gaza Health Ministry.
Analysis & context
Analysis & Context
Legally, East Jerusalem is considered occupied Palestinian territory according to UN resolutions, making the closure of the UK consulate there a violation of international law. In a broader context, Israel faces increasing pressure from the international community due to its policies in the occupied Palestinian territories, including settlement expansion and military attacks.
Politically, the UK's position reflects a shift in British foreign policy towards Israel, aiming to challenge what it views as human rights violations and international crimes. This change also reflects growing tensions between Israel and major Western powers, particularly after Israel's attacks on Gaza in October 2023, which led to the deaths and displacement of thousands of Palestinians.
From a humanitarian perspective, Grieve's remarks highlight the importance of continuing to provide international assistance and oversight to the Palestinian people in the West Bank and Gaza, where these areas face significant challenges due to the ongoing conflict.




