Sourced fact
The News
Former Israeli Defense Minister Yoav Gallant announced on Sunday that Israeli intelligence agencies had misinterpreted a message received in Israel from Hamas prior to the October 7, 2023 attacks. According to Anadolu Agency, Gallant told the Israeli military radio that the message, which reached Israel indirectly via the Shin Bet internal security service, stated that Hamas would "shake the prisons."
Gallant clarified that both Shin Bet and Amana, the Military Intelligence Directorate, interpreted this message as referring to the kidnapping of Israeli researcher Elizabet Tsourkoff in Iraq, while other reports indicate that Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar sent a warning about an "earthquake in the prisons" due to the issue of Palestinian detainees. According to the source text, Elizabet Tsourkoff was released in September 2025.
On his part, Israeli opposition leader Yair Golan accused Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of ignoring the warnings that reached him before the events, considering that Netanyahu chose to ignore all available warnings. Golan wrote on X, formerly known as Twitter, that Netanyahu received "every warning in the world" but rejected them, citing reports published by Haaretz and The New York Times about intelligence information reaching the Prime Minister.
Golan also accused Netanyahu of weakening the Palestinian Authority and silencing voices that tried to warn of an impending disaster, calling for the formation of a state investigation committee into the failures of all systems, starting with Netanyahu himself. Netanyahu has consistently rejected calls to form an official investigative committee regarding the October 7 events, and his office denied reports claiming that the UAE leader warned him of Hamas's major operation just days before.
Analysis & context
Analysis & Context
From an analytical perspective, these statements highlight a deep debate within Israeli society regarding the effectiveness of security agencies and their ability to interpret complex intelligence signals before major attacks. The contradiction between Shin Bet's interpretation of the message as a warning of civilian kidnapping and Gallant's interpretation of it as a signal of a large-scale attack raises questions about the accuracy of intelligence analysis during critical moments.
In a broader context, this debate is part of an escalating internal political struggle between Israel's current government and opposition parties that condemn severe security failures. The opposition's demand for an international investigation reflects a strong public desire to learn the truth about how clear warnings turned into a bloody disaster that cast a shadow over Gaza and Israel itself.
The issue of "shaking the prisons" is central to understanding Hamas's motives and strategic objectives before the war, as reports indicate that the movement planned to exploit the situation inside Israeli prisons as part of a comprehensive attack. This context links internal Israeli issues such as prisoners' rights and political negotiations with external military escalation that led to a devastating war in Gaza.
Netanyahu's refusal to open an official investigation despite increasing evidence of prior warnings strengthens divisions within Israeli society and weakens trust in security and judicial institutions. These divisions may negatively affect the country's internal stability and delay necessary future security or political reforms.



